Analysis of Shipwreck 31CR314: Was the Queen Anne's Revenge Really Discovered?
Source: allthatsinteresting.com
In the book X Marks the Spot, two chapters discuss shipwreck 31CR314.
This article analyzes the evidence from the two chapters.
Chapter Nine
Archaeologists examine the findings and possibly the remains of Queen Anne’s Revenge. Blackbeard operated in North Carolina, and this was the route he most likely sailed. From there, as recorded, the bloody battle between Lieutenant Maynard and Blackbeard on the morning of November 22, 1718, ultimately led to the pirate's defeat.
In the fall of 1996, Mike Daniel surveyed the inlet's entrance channel and outer bar. The recovered artifacts included a brass blunderbuss barrel, cannonballs, and a bronze bell dating to 1705. Of two hundred shipwrecks, eight may be considered the Queen Anne’s Revenge. The investigation had three objectives. First, an array of specialists was necessary, forming an archaeological dream team. Second, they needed to understand the layout and environmental conditions. Third, the team needed to investigate key elements to identify Blackbeard’s flagship.
The recorded shipwrecks included the Queen Anne’s Revenge, which carried thirty-six to forty guns and was two hundred to three hundred tons; the Adventure, which carried eight to ten guns and eighty tons; and El Salvador, which held eight guns and was one hundred ten tons. The other ships that were lost carried no guns. Three large anchors, two hundred fifty to three hundred fifty tons, were too large for the Adventure, El Salvador, or others. Nothing conclusive identified 31CR314 as Blackbeard’s ship or ruled it out of this five-week project.
From September 14 to October 16, 1998, divers recorded 507 hours and 25 minutes of diving time. Planks found were positively identified as European red pine. The recovered artifacts most likely came from the officers’ quarters, and a fourth anchor was discovered. The artifact was nearly identical to the Whydah pirate ship. Additionally, the gold dust samples were not typically found in the area. Finally, eighteen cannons were found, two of which were loaded, providing more evidence of Queen Anne’s Revenge.
Chapter nine explains the various instruments used to support this evidence. Geologists created twenty-five digital maps surveying the Beaufort Inlet from the 1700s to the present. Estimates show the shipwreck was buried eighty percent of the time. They also explained that, in twenty feet of water now, it was only ten to twelve feet deep at the time of the wreckage.
Marine geologists used high-resolution bathymetric and side-scan sonar to survey the site; only two such systems existed in the United States. Archaeologists used remote sensing instruments, including magnetometers and magnetic gradiometers. Returning in the fall of 1999, the Surface Interval Dive Company recorded 2,064 readings. They found two more small cannons, one from England and one from Sweden, bringing the total to twenty-one cannons. From September 25 to October 13, 2000, the final major expedition found 184 artifacts. The following spring, they found another cannon.
This ship was originally a French slave ship named the Concorde, which Blackbeard presumably overtook in late 1717; he increased the number of guns to forty and renamed it Queen Anne’s Revenge. Blackbeard continued to capture many ships, including the Protestant and Adventure. While sailing through Topsail Inlet, the Queen Anne’s Revenge and the Adventure were reported grounded on the outer bar. He sailed off in a smaller ship and received a king’s pardon at the colonial capital of Bath. For the next few months, Blackbeard continued his piratical spree and, in the end, faced Royal Navy lieutenant Robert Maynard, who defeated him in 1718.

In 1996, during a magnetometer survey, treasure hunters reportedly took thirty artifacts, including a dated bronze bell, a stamped musketoon barrel, and inscribed-sounding lead. In 1997, a post-disturbance survey and mapping discovered the main ballast pile, three anchors, fifteen cannons, and three hundred thirty-three small artifacts. 1998 is marked as a continual assessment. In addition to ballast stones, barrel hoops, deadeyes, and lead shots, archaeologists found three additional cannons, bringing the total to 409 artifacts.
In June and October 1999, archaeologists conducted a diver-positioned magnetometer survey. They found two more cannons, along with 48 related and 51 small artifacts. The 2000 field season retrieved a section of the wooden hull and 117 artifacts. Since November 1996, archaeologists have recovered over 2,000 artifacts.
The chapter supports the claim that the bronze bell found with HIS MARIA and ANO DE 1709 inscribed marks Spanish or Portuguese origin. Two lead pump sieves were recovered, resembling the ones found on El Nuevo Constante, wrecked in 1766. Anchor stocks were made of white oak and tropical bloodwood.
Both chapters support detailed facts on the artifacts discovered. Chapter nine goes into more detail about the weather conditions and an archaeologist's journey during the excavation. As much as I would love to believe the supporting evidence of this shipwreck being Queen Anne’s Revenge, the details, in my opinion, don’t match up. For example, chapter nine explains that only a handful of ships recorded disappearing in the area could be the wreck, and it could not have been a merchant ship. Still, chapter ten explains that many merchant ships carried efficiently around twenty guns. The Queen Anne’s Revenge allegedly had forty guns, and only twenty-two were discovered in the site area.
Another supporting fact is that the only French-made artifact was a pewter syringe on a supposed French slave ship that should exhibit some evidence of slave trading goods. However, the bell found on the ship was Spanish and most likely not transferred from another vessel; not to mention, the bell's date, 1709, does not match the missing vessel's building date.
Lusardi, W. R. (2007). The Beaufort Inlet Shipwreck Artifact Assemblage, X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of Piracy (pp.196-218). Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida.
Wild-Ramsing, M. U. (2007). The Pirate Ship Queen Anne’s Revenge, X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of Piracy (pp.160-195). Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida.
In the fall of 1996, Mike Daniel surveyed the inlet's entrance channel and outer bar. The recovered artifacts included a brass blunderbuss barrel, cannonballs, and a bronze bell dating to 1705. Of two hundred shipwrecks, eight may be considered the Queen Anne’s Revenge. The investigation had three objectives. First, an array of specialists was necessary, forming an archaeological dream team. Second, they needed to understand the layout and environmental conditions. Third, the team needed to investigate key elements to identify Blackbeard’s flagship.
The recorded shipwrecks included the Queen Anne’s Revenge, which carried thirty-six to forty guns and was two hundred to three hundred tons; the Adventure, which carried eight to ten guns and eighty tons; and El Salvador, which held eight guns and was one hundred ten tons. The other ships that were lost carried no guns. Three large anchors, two hundred fifty to three hundred fifty tons, were too large for the Adventure, El Salvador, or others. Nothing conclusive identified 31CR314 as Blackbeard’s ship or ruled it out of this five-week project.
From September 14 to October 16, 1998, divers recorded 507 hours and 25 minutes of diving time. Planks found were positively identified as European red pine. The recovered artifacts most likely came from the officers’ quarters, and a fourth anchor was discovered. The artifact was nearly identical to the Whydah pirate ship. Additionally, the gold dust samples were not typically found in the area. Finally, eighteen cannons were found, two of which were loaded, providing more evidence of Queen Anne’s Revenge.
Chapter nine explains the various instruments used to support this evidence. Geologists created twenty-five digital maps surveying the Beaufort Inlet from the 1700s to the present. Estimates show the shipwreck was buried eighty percent of the time. They also explained that, in twenty feet of water now, it was only ten to twelve feet deep at the time of the wreckage.
Marine geologists used high-resolution bathymetric and side-scan sonar to survey the site; only two such systems existed in the United States. Archaeologists used remote sensing instruments, including magnetometers and magnetic gradiometers. Returning in the fall of 1999, the Surface Interval Dive Company recorded 2,064 readings. They found two more small cannons, one from England and one from Sweden, bringing the total to twenty-one cannons. From September 25 to October 13, 2000, the final major expedition found 184 artifacts. The following spring, they found another cannon.
Source: pirateshipvallarta.com
Chapter Ten

Source: thehistoryblog.com
In June and October 1999, archaeologists conducted a diver-positioned magnetometer survey. They found two more cannons, along with 48 related and 51 small artifacts. The 2000 field season retrieved a section of the wooden hull and 117 artifacts. Since November 1996, archaeologists have recovered over 2,000 artifacts.
Analysis
Source: plush-overground.com
Another supporting fact is that the only French-made artifact was a pewter syringe on a supposed French slave ship that should exhibit some evidence of slave trading goods. However, the bell found on the ship was Spanish and most likely not transferred from another vessel; not to mention, the bell's date, 1709, does not match the missing vessel's building date.
Most of the artifacts found were English, including pewter plates marked “London” and a Tudor Rose, indicative of King Henry Tudor's era. The surveying instruments recovered were dated post-battle. If this evidence were presented in court as proof, beyond a reasonable doubt, that this shipwreck was Queen Anne’s Revenge, it would not hold up, and the case would be thrown out.
A recovered brass musketoon barrel and loaded cannons suggest a battle likely caused the shipwreck. On the other hand, it may have simply been another merchant vessel captured by Blackbeard during his pirate raids and went down in battle against Lieutenant Maynard. In any case, as much as I would like to see the dedicated work and research from all the individuals confirm the location of the lost Queen Anne’s Revenge, I believe the quest should go on.
References
References
Lusardi, W. R. (2007). The Beaufort Inlet Shipwreck Artifact Assemblage, X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of Piracy (pp.196-218). Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida.
Wild-Ramsing, M. U. (2007). The Pirate Ship Queen Anne’s Revenge, X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of Piracy (pp.160-195). Gainesville, Florida: University Press of Florida.









Comments
Post a Comment